Star rating: 4/5 stars
Synopsis: via Goodreads–
All’s faire in love and war for two sworn enemies who indulge in a harmless flirtation in a laugh-out-loud rom-com from debut author, Jen DeLuca.
Emily knew there would be strings attached when she relocated to the small town of Willow Creek, Maryland, for the summer to help her sister recover from an accident, but who could anticipate getting roped into volunteering for the local Renaissance Faire alongside her teenaged niece? Or that the irritating and inscrutable schoolteacher in charge of the volunteers would be so annoying that she finds it impossible to stop thinking about him?
The faire is Simon’s family legacy and from the start he makes clear he doesn’t have time for Emily’s lighthearted approach to life, her oddball Shakespeare conspiracy theories, or her endless suggestions for new acts to shake things up. Yet on the faire grounds he becomes a different person, flirting freely with Emily when she’s in her revealing wench’s costume. But is this attraction real, or just part of the characters they’re portraying?
This summer was only ever supposed to be a pit stop on the way to somewhere else for Emily, but soon she can’t seem to shake the fantasy of establishing something more with Simon, or a permanent home of her own in Willow Creek.
General information: This book was published in 2019 by Berkley.
A romcom set at a Renaissance Faire? Yes please!
For real, though, I thoroughly enjoyed this book. It was heartwarming and cute and swoony, all the best things about reading a romcom.
For a romcom, though, it felt pretty light on the “com.” It didn’t make me laugh out loud at any point like The Unhoneymooners did, and also didn’t make me exhale heavily out of my nose, like most funny books do. (I’m not the only one here who does that, right?)
However, I still fell in love with the characters and the town of Willow Creek (sidenote: isn’t that the name of a town in the Sims 4?). I loved Simon, especially, and his struggle to keep up his brother’s legacy. I loved the small-town atmosphere of the book- and I’m not usually one for small towns in real life. This one, though, was charming and filled with a cast of supportive characters. Can I move there?
This book had me swooning every time the main couple so much as kissed, and I had to put it down in a couple of parts because I was so emotionally involved in the main couple.
However- and this is a big ‘however’- looking back, I honestly don’t see what attracted them to each other in the first place. They hate each other out of nowhere, which, fair enough, that happens all the time. But then suddenly, they’re incredibly attracted to each other? Which, again, fair enough (or faire enough?), that happens too. But then, boom, they’re in love! And have been for a while! Who could have predicted that?
It’s a romcom, so I was willing to suspend disbelief while I was reading, but having had some time to think about it, I just don’t fully believe in the main couple. It was fun and lighthearted and swoony (have I mentioned how swoony it was?) but it felt like something was missing.
I’m honestly not sure if I want to read the next book in the series yet because of this. I liked Stacey’s character but I wasn’t very invested in her, and I’m not sure I could read a whole book about her. That being said, I’d probably get Well Played if it was on sale? Just not right now.
However, this author can write the hell out of a kiss scene.
Do I plan to read this again? Yes, probably. Would I recommend this to romcom fans? Sure. But my rating of 4 stars is probably closer to a 3.5 because of the issues I had with the romance development.
Thanks for reading! Have you read this? What were your thoughts?